How Do I File a Claim Against Another Person’s Insurance?
November 24, 2021

How Do I File a Claim Against Another Person’s Insurance?

Since the laws regulating first-party and third-party claims are different, it is important that you understand your rights and responsibilities in both situations. In a first-party claim, you have a direct contract with your insurance carrier, which requires your insurer to meet all of the terms of your policy. You don’t have a direct contract with the insurance company in a third-party claim, and their primary responsibility is to their own policyholder.

One of the first things you may have to do after a vehicle accident makes an insurance claim for damages. Even if another motorist caused the damage, you can submit a claim with either your own insurance company (a “first-party” claim) or the other driver’s insurance company (a “third-party” claim).

When you make an insurance claim with the insurance company of another driver is known as a third-party claim. Because you’re filing a claim with an insurer with whom you may or may not have a policy, you’re referred to as the third party.

You may also be able to submit a claim with the at-fault driver’s insurance provider when you are involved in a car crash that was not your fault to cover expenses for the following:  transportation, car repairs, while your car is being fixed, and any related medical expenses.

While being in a car accident is stressful and time-consuming, learning how to file an insurance claim against someone else is crucial. If you’re in an automobile accident, you must call two distinct parties as quickly as possible. Every time you are in an automobile accident, your insurance company should be notified.

However, you should call a car accident lawyer if you have been injured or if the cause of the collision has still yet to be identified. There are numerous reasons why someone should hire a car accident lawyer, with the benefits far outweighing the cost.

When Should (Or Shouldn’t) I File A Claim?

When you are in an accident with some other motorist, you should file a claim as soon as possible. Although some people may consider trying to negotiate an out-of-pocket payment, skipping the claim process may have unexpected effects. For instance, the motorist may discover extra damage to their car. Furthermore, your car insurance can often assist to cover property damage or injury expenses, as well as legal fees.

So, when is it appropriate to not file a claim? As a general guideline, you should not file a claim when you are confident that there is no damage to the other car or other people’s property. Check to see if the cost of repairs is less than or equal to your policy deductible. Although it may be tempting to deal with problems behind closed doors, you always face the danger of being sued afterward. Therefore, it’s often preferable to be safe rather than sorry.

Information to Get From Your Insurance Representative

Determine what you are protected for by speaking with your insurance representative. This includes knowing how much your deductible is and how much time you have before the insurance claim deadline. If you’ll be renting a car while your own is being fixed, it’s also a good idea to double-check your rental reimbursement coverage.

This changes based on the insurance provider, so communicate with an official from your organization to comprehend how long you have to file a claim. It is important to remember that there is a time limit for filing the claim and then submitting the associated bills. Getting all of these details on hand will be extremely useful if you need to file an auto accident lawsuit.

How Third-Party Insurance Claims Work

In States With No-fault Insurance

After a car accident, if you have no-fault insurance, you would file a claim with your own insurer for your medical expenses. Personal injury protection (PIP) pays for medical expenses up to the limits of your car insurance policy. In some states, personal injury protection (also known as no-fault insurance) is required, while in others it is optional.

After an auto accident in a no-fault state, you typically file a third-party claim for property damage.

In States Without No-Fault Insurance

You can usually submit third-party insurance claims for property damage and medical expenditures if you live in a state that does not offer no-fault insurance.

The Third-Party Claim Process

The claim process is handled differently by each insurance carrier. During a third-party claim, you’ll most likely work with a claim representative or insurance adjuster. The insurance adjuster may ask their insured client for information regarding the accident, and you may provide that information (the third party). They may also check each vehicle’s damage (in person or through photos) and get a copy of the police report.

The adjuster will establish who is to blame for the accident based on their findings. If their insured customer is judged to be at fault for the accident, the insurance company may pay your third-party claim. If your car is damaged, for instance, the company may pay the collision repair shop directly or issue you a compensation check.

Working with a shop in their direct repair network may be suggested by the other insurer. However, you can choose your own repair shop. Getting an estimate from a mechanic or body shop is an excellent way to predict how much repair work will cost, according to the Insurance Information Institute III. It’s a good idea to ask questions about how each type of store would handle the claim, then weigh the pros and cons of both alternatives before making a selection.

Ø  Send a letter stating your plan to file a claim.

It’s a good idea to write a letter to the other motorist shortly after the collision informing them of your intention to sue them for the cost of the repairs. If getting a repair estimate will take some time, you should do this. If the other driver has insurance, the letter can be forwarded to their firm.

Ø  Get a repair estimate and work out your claim.

Seek a quote, unless the amount is disputed, there is no need to get a second price. Keep the original quote and photocopy it. Photocopy your receipts if you paid for towing and keep the originals. You are not obligated to use the repairer recommended by the other party.

Ø  Make contact with the person who caused the accident and try to reach an agreement.

The goal of contacting the people who caused the accident is to give them the option of paying for the damages or negotiating with you to reach an arrangement without going to court. Going to court should only be used as a last choice because it is time consuming, expensive, and stressful.

When you’ve gathered all of your information, write the other driver a demand letter stating your claim for damages and attaching copies of quotations and towing receipts. The letter should be typed or written carefully by hand.

If you know the people who caused the accident have insurance, you should also write a letter describing your claim to their insurance provider. The insurance company will either accept or deny that they should pay for the accident in response to your letter. Your vehicle will almost certainly be inspected by one of the insurer’s assessors.

Ø  Reaching an agreement

You can contact the other motorist to negotiate, or they can contact you. You can talk over the phone and come to an agreement. Talk about who is to blame for the accident and see if you can come to an agreement on a percentage of the blame. This can be used to calculate the payment amount.

Ø  Consider legal action

If you don’t hear back from the persons who caused the accident, or if their insurance company refuses to recognize its client’s liability, you can pursue legal action.

Ø  Prepare written statements

It is essential to be well-prepared before beginning your claim. Make a statement on what transpired in the accident and date it. Request that anyone who witnessed the accident and is willing to submit a statement write a statement describing what they saw.


Auto insurance is intended to keep you safe in the event of an accident. It is, however, intended to protect you even if you are not directly at fault. Even though you are a careful driver with a clean driving record, you could be involved in a crash induced by some other driver. It is vital that you are protected during these times

Tags: accident, auto, car, claims, coverage, insurance

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *